– Total includes league and cup matches, plus fouls won for free kicks/penalties directly scored, as of February 2020
Previous highest (2018/19): Ashley Presley – 6
1. Warren Ralph – 4
– Graeme Smith
2. Aaron Aquilina – 3
– Andy Chilvers
3. Richard Buckle – 2
– Jonathan James
– Kevin Kogel
4. Mark Baker – 1
– Nathen Cox
– Joshua Golding
– Max O’Neill
– Steven Passey